The Trap: What Happened to Our Dream of Freedom
“If one steps back and looks at what freedom actually means for us today, it’s a strange and limited kind of freedom. The West apparently fought the Cold War for ‘individual freedom,’ yet it is still something our leaders continually promise to give us. Abroad, in Iraq and Afghanistan, the attempt to force ‘freedom’ on to other people has led to bloody mayhem. This, in turn, has helped inspire terrorist attacks in Britain. In response, the government has dismantled long-standing laws that were designed to protect individual freedom.”
This first episode examines the rise of a mathematical model about human behaviour called Game Theory developed during the Cold War and the way in which its premises since filtered into economic thought. The programme traces the development of the theory with particular reference to the work of John Nash, who constructed such models for which he won the Nobel Prize in Economics. He invented system games reflecting his beliefs about human behaviour, including one he called “Fuck You Buddy” (later published as “So Long Sucker”), in which the only way to win was to betray your playing partner. These games were mathematically coherent but only worked correctly as long as the players obeyed the ground rules that they should behave selfishly and try to outwit their opponents. As the 1960s became the 70s, the theories of a Scottish psychiatrist R.D Laing and the models of Nash began to converge, producing a widespread popular belief that the state (like a surrogate family) was purely and simply a mechanism of social control which calculatedly kept power out of the hands of the public. This episode shows how this belief allowed economic models that left no room for altruism to unrealistically look credible, and then how this went on to serve the free-market beliefs of Margaret Thatcher who sincerely believed that by dismantling as much of the British state as possible and placing former national institutions into the hands of public shareholders, a new form of ‘social equilibrium’ would be reached. This was a return to Nash’s work, in which the claim was that if everyone was pursuing their own interests, a stable, yet ‘dynamic’ society could result. But as the mathematically modelled society is run on data—performance targets, quotas and statistics—it is precisely these figures combined with the false belief that human selfishness can provide stability, that has created “The Trap.”
The second episode follows on from many of the ideas of the first to develop the theme that drugs such as Prozac and lists of psychological symptoms which might indicate anxiety or depression are being used to normalise behaviour and make humans behave more predictably, like machines. This is not presented as a conspiracy, but as a logical outcome of market-driven self-diagnosis by check-lists based on normal symptoms of human emotion.
The final part in this series focuses on the concepts of positive and negative liberty introduced in the 1950s by Isaiah Berlin. The episode briefly explains how negative liberty could be defined as freedom from coercion and positive liberty as the opportunity to strive to fulfil one’s potential.